E-Invoicing Mandate & Law 8 min readPublished

What Is a Structured E-Invoice? Germany's Two Legal Invoice Types

What is a structured e-invoice under German VAT law? The legal text, a comparison with other invoices like PDF and paper, and a table of what is allowed until when.

docutools.pro Editorial TeamEditorial Team

Key takeaways

  • A structured e-invoice is a machine-readable invoice data set in a format that meets EN 16931 or an agreed format with complete data extraction.
  • Every other invoice, including a PDF sent by e-mail, is an other invoice (sonstige Rechnung) under § 14(1) sentence 4 UStG.
  • Between businesses established in Germany, other invoices are generally allowed until 31 December 2026, and in 2027 only for issuers with up to EUR 800,000 turnover in 2026 or via EDI.
  • Invoices to consumers, invoices up to EUR 250 and invoices involving a business not established in Germany can stay PDF or paper.
On this page

A structured e-invoice is an invoice whose data is issued, transmitted and received as a machine-readable data set, usually XML, in a format that meets the European standard EN 16931. German VAT law calls it an electronic invoice (§ 14(1) sentence 3 UStG). Everything else, including a PDF sent by e-mail, is an "other invoice".

This matters to international finance teams because German law since 2025 has only these two invoice types, and the allowed type depends on who the parties are and on the date. Below you find the legal wording, a comparison table, a timeline and five scenarios. The broader definition and the formats are covered in what is an e-invoice.

The short answer: structured e-invoice or other invoice?

A structured e-invoice is required when the supplier and the customer are both established in Germany, the customer buys for its business and no exemption applies (Section 14 of the German VAT Act, § 14(2) sentence 2 no. 1 UStG). In every other case an other invoice (sonstige Rechnung) is allowed, and during the transition until the end of 2027 it is still allowed in many mandatory cases as well.

  • Structured e-invoice: domestic B2B invoices; mandatory from 2027 for issuers with more than EUR 800,000 prior-year turnover, from 2028 for all.
  • Other invoice: consumers, small amounts, tickets, small businesses as issuers, VAT-exempt supplies under § 4 nos. 8 to 29 UStG, cross-border cases with a foreign party, and the transition cases of § 27(38) UStG.

What does German law say word for word?

Since 1 January 2025, § 14(1) UStG (opens in a new tab) defines both invoice types. The key sentences, translated:

SentenceWording (translated, shortened)What it means in practice
2An invoice can be transmitted as an electronic invoice or, subject to paragraph 2, as an other invoiceBoth are valid invoices for VAT purposes
3An electronic invoice is "issued, transmitted and received in a structured electronic format" and "enables electronic processing"XRechnung, ZUGFeRD from 2.0.1 (not MINIMUM or BASIC WL), qualifying EDI
4An other invoice is an invoice "transmitted in another electronic format or on paper"Paper, PDF, scan, Word file, invoice in the e-mail body
5Electronic transmission needs the recipient's consent, unless an e-invoice is mandatoryPaper never needs consent; a PDF always does
6 and 7The format must follow EN 16931 or be agreed, if the required data can be "correctly and completely" extractedThe test of whether a format can be an e-invoice at all

A quotable version: a structured e-invoice is an invoice data set that software can process without retyping, in an EN 16931 format or an agreed format with complete data extraction.

The German Federal Ministry of Finance (BMF) adds in its letter of 15 October 2024 (para. 7) that other invoices include "PDF files without integrated data sets, image files or e-mails". Para. 6 adds that a human-readable copy is optional for an e-invoice, because a viewer application can display the XML.

Structured e-invoice vs other invoice: comparison

CriterionStructured e-invoiceOther invoice (sonstige Rechnung)
Legal basis§ 14(1) sentences 3 and 6 UStG§ 14(1) sentence 4 UStG
Typical formXML (XRechnung, UBL or CII) or PDF/A-3 with embedded XML (ZUGFeRD, Factur-X)Paper, PDF, image file, e-mail text
ReadabilityMachine-readable; a visual copy is optional (para. 6)Readable by a person
Recipient's consentNot needed where the e-invoice is mandatoryPaper: never; electronic: always
Domestic B2BMandatory, with transition rules until end of 2027Only during the transition or under an exemption
Mandatory content§§ 14(4) and 14a UStG, in the structured part§§ 14(4) and 14a UStG, with relief under §§ 33, 34, 34a UStDV
Deadline to issueSix months after the supply (§ 14(2) sentence 2 UStG)The same, where an invoice is required

The content rules are almost identical. The difference is the format and who must agree to it.

Which invoice form is allowed until when?

The table applies to invoices between two businesses established in Germany where no exemption applies.

Invoice formLegal typeAllowed in domestic B2B
Paper invoiceOther invoiceUntil 31 Dec 2026 always; in 2027 only if the issuer's 2026 total turnover was up to EUR 800,000
PDF by e-mailOther invoiceUntil 31 Dec 2026 with consent; in 2027 only with the turnover condition and consent
Scan, photo, Word fileOther invoiceSame as the PDF
ZUGFeRD or Factur-X in MINIMUM or BASIC WLOther invoice, as not EN 16931 compliant (paras. 25 and 30)Same as the PDF
EDI without complete EN 16931 extractionOther invoiceWith consent until 31 Dec 2027 (§ 27(38) no. 3 UStG), regardless of turnover
EDI with complete extractionStructured e-invoice (§ 14(1) sentence 6 no. 2 UStG)Also after 2027 (paras. 33 and 65)
XRechnung; ZUGFeRD from 2.0.1 in BASIC, EN 16931, EXTENDED or XRECHNUNGStructured e-invoiceNo end date

One special case is the hybrid invoice whose PDF part differs from its XML. In ZUGFeRD the XML is the leading part (para. 31). If the PDF shows different mandatory details, for example a different VAT amount, para. 32 says it may be a further other invoice, to be assessed under § 14c UStG (VAT shown on an invoice but not owed). Input VAT can then only be deducted from the structured part.

When can an invoice stay PDF or paper permanently?

The transition dates only matter where an e-invoice would be mandatory. These cases keep the other invoice after 2027:

CaseLegal basisNote
Invoice to a consumer§ 14(2) sentence 2 no. 1 UStG covers business customers onlyConstruction-related work for consumers needs an invoice, but not an e-invoice (no. 3)
Legal entity that is not a business§ 14(2) sentence 2 no. 2 UStGPublic procurement rules such as the federal E-Rechnungsverordnung apply separately (para. 20)
Small-amount invoice up to EUR 250§ 33 sentence 4 UStDVThe total invoice amount counts
Passenger ticket§ 34(1) sentence 2 UStDVPassenger transport only
Invoice from a small business (Kleinunternehmer)§ 34a sentence 4 UStDVApplies to issuing; receiving e-invoices is still required
VAT-exempt supplies under § 4 nos. 8 to 29 UStG§ 14(2) sentence 2 UStGCheck mixed invoices with taxable parts separately (see below)
Supplier or customer not established in Germany§ 14(2) sentence 2 no. 1 UStG, para. 16Paper, or electronic with consent

For a step-by-step test of each invoice, use the checklist of German e-invoicing exemptions. The EUR 250 rule is explained in the post on small-amount invoices in Germany.

Timeline: how long does the transition last?

The transition rules are in § 27(38) UStG (opens in a new tab) and explained in paras. 62 to 65 of the BMF letter of 15 October 2024.

Date of supplyOther invoice allowed forLegal basis
1 Jan 2025 to 31 Dec 2026All issuers; paper always, electronic with consent§ 27(38) no. 1 UStG, para. 63
1 Jan 2027 to 31 Dec 2027Issuers with total turnover of up to EUR 800,000 in 2026§ 27(38) no. 2 UStG, para. 64
1 Jan 2027 to 31 Dec 2027EDI with consent, regardless of turnover§ 27(38) no. 3 UStG, para. 65
From 1 Jan 2028Only the permanent cases above§ 14(2) UStG

There is no transition for receiving (para. 62). How the EUR 800,000 threshold works for groups, self-billing and third-party invoicing is covered in Germany e-invoicing 2027.

Five scenarios for international teams

A US company's German subsidiary invoices a German customer. The subsidiary is established in Germany, so it issues structured e-invoices to German business customers: from 2027 if its 2026 turnover exceeded EUR 800,000, and from 2028 in any case.

A Dutch supplier invoices a German GmbH. The supplier is not established in Germany and has no German establishment involved in the supply, so the German mandate does not apply (para. 16). Paper is possible, and a PDF with the customer's consent.

A German consultancy with EUR 600,000 turnover in 2026. It may still send PDF invoices to business customers in 2027 if they agree. Many larger customers will switch their accounts payable to structured data from 2027, so moving early avoids a second change later.

A group exchanging EDIFACT invoices. The EDI flow may continue until the end of 2027. After that, it counts only if the VAT data can be extracted correctly and completely into an EN 16931 format (paras. 33 and 34).

A German customer refuses the e-invoice. Under para. 42 the customer has "no right" to an other invoice instead. The supplier has met its VAT obligations if it issued an e-invoice and can prove it tried to deliver it, for example with a transmission log.

What stays the same?

An other invoice still needs every mandatory detail of § 14(4) UStG, and the authenticity of origin, integrity of content and legibility must be ensured (§ 14(3) UStG). For paper or PDF invoices you can work through a German invoice requirements checker.

One point on penalties. § 26a(2) no. 1 UStG covers failing to issue an invoice, or issuing it late, with a fine of up to EUR 5,000 (§ 26a(3) UStG). According to a summary by the Hanover Chamber of Commerce (IHK Hannover) (opens in a new tab), the BMF letter of 15 October 2026 states that issuing an other invoice instead of a mandatory e-invoice is not an administrative offence under that provision. The e-invoicing obligation itself remains. For broken XML files and the input VAT effects, see e-invoice format errors vs content errors.

How to check the invoice type with docutools.pro

  1. Received a PDF? Open the ZUGFeRD extractor and click "Choose PDF". If you see an "Invoice summary" and the "XML source", the file has an embedded data set. If the tool finds none, the PDF is an other invoice. The extractor runs in your browser, and the file does not leave your computer.
  2. Read the profile. The extractor does not detect the profile for you. In the XML source, find ram:GuidelineSpecifiedDocumentContextParameter (BT-24). If it contains urn:factur-x.eu:1p0:minimum or urn:factur-x.eu:1p0:basicwl, the file is not an e-invoice under § 14(1) sentence 6 UStG. Use "Download XML" to save the data set and extract the XML from the PDF for further checks.
  3. Validate the XML. Upload the XML to the XRechnung validator. The file is sent to our server for the check. The "KoSIT validation" checks the way the KoSIT validator does (configuration 2026-08-31) for files identified as XRechnung 3.0 or urn:cen.eu:en16931:2017. Other identifiers, including valid ones such as ZUGFeRD BASIC or EXTENDED, are rejected with "No official validation scenario matches this file" and no business rule is checked, so that message alone does not make a file an other invoice.
  4. Read the result. "KoSIT-conformant / Valid XRechnung" means format and business rules pass. "Not KoSIT-conformant" lists the failed rules; fix notes for single codes are in the list of XRechnung validation errors.
  5. Paper and PDF invoices. In the requirements checker, use the "Checklist" mode with 13 items, or the short list with 5 items for invoices up to EUR 250.

The free plan of the viewer allows 2 uploads per day up to 500 KB each; more is available on the Pro plan. More guides on deadlines and scope are on the e-invoicing mandate hub.

Sources

Last reviewed: November 2026

This article is general information, not tax or legal advice.

Tags:E-InvoicingGermanyVATStructured Data

Tools for this article

Frequently asked questions

Is a PDF invoice a structured e-invoice?

No. A PDF without an embedded data set is an other invoice (sonstige Rechnung) under German VAT law since 1 January 2025. The BMF letter of 15 October 2024 (para. 7) names PDF files without integrated data sets, image files and e-mails explicitly. A ZUGFeRD or Factur-X PDF from version 2.0.1 is different: its embedded XML is the structured e-invoice, except in the MINIMUM and BASIC WL profiles.

Do foreign suppliers have to send structured e-invoices to German customers?

Not under the German VAT mandate. The obligation in § 14(2) sentence 2 no. 1 UStG applies only when both the supplier and the customer are established in Germany. If one party is not, the invoice can be on paper or, with the recipient's consent, a PDF or an e-invoice. A German permanent establishment involved in the supply counts as established in Germany.

Is EDI a structured e-invoice in Germany?

It can be. An agreed format such as EDIFACT is a structured e-invoice if the required VAT data can be extracted correctly and completely into a format that meets or is interoperable with EN 16931 (§ 14(1) sentence 6 no. 2 UStG). EDI invoices that do not meet this test remain allowed until 31 December 2027 with the recipient's consent.

Can a customer in Germany refuse a structured e-invoice?

A domestic business customer has no right to demand a paper or PDF invoice instead. Under para. 42 of the BMF letter of 15 October 2024, the issuer has met its VAT obligations if it issued an e-invoice and can prove it tried to deliver it properly, for example with a transmission log. Since 2025 every domestic business must be able to receive e-invoices.

Topic hubMore on E-Invoicing Mandate & LawWho has to receive and issue e-invoices in Germany, and when? Deadlines, exemptions and the legal basis of the German mandate.